In the world of books, the term bestseller carries a powerful allure. For aspiring and established authors alike, it often represents the pinnacle of success—a golden badge that confirms not only popularity but, seemingly, quality and importance. Walk into any bookstore or browse an online platform, and you’ll see entire sections dedicated to bestsellers, with covers proudly labeled as New York Times Bestseller, Amazon Chart Topper, or #1 National Bestseller. But what actually makes a book a bestseller? And is that really the ultimate goal every author should chase?

This blog post dives into what defines a bestseller, the mechanics behind achieving that status, and why, in many cases, authors might do better to aim for something deeper and more lasting.

The Anatomy of a Bestseller

Let’s start with the basics: What exactly is a bestseller?

At its most straightforward, a bestseller is a book that sells a large number of copies in a relatively short period of time. But the specifics get murky depending on the context.

Bestseller Lists: A Brief Overview

There are several major bestseller lists, each with its own criteria:

  • The New York Times Bestseller List: Perhaps the most prestigious and influential, the NYT list is curated based on sales from a select group of bookstores and online retailers. It is not purely quantitative—editorial discretion plays a role.

  • Amazon Best Sellers: Updated hourly, Amazon’s rankings are based purely on sales data from its platform. This includes digital (Kindle) and physical formats, and is category-specific.

  • USA Today and Publishers Weekly: These lists rely more on raw sales data from a broad range of retailers, offering a different but equally valuable snapshot of what’s selling.

The thresholds vary. In the U.S., selling 5,000 to 10,000 copies in a single week might land you on a national list. On Amazon, you might reach bestseller status in a niche category with as few as 100 sales in a day, depending on the competition.

What Drives a Book to Bestseller Status?

A variety of factors can propel a book into the coveted bestseller zone, and while quality plays a role, it’s rarely the only ingredient. Here are some of the most common elements:

1. Pre-Orders and Launch Strategy

Pre-orders are a powerful tool. When a large number of readers commit to buying a book before it’s released, those sales are often counted on launch day—creating a sales spike that boosts rankings dramatically.

2. Platform and Influence

Authors with built-in audiences—such as celebrities, influencers, or entrepreneurs—have a significant advantage. When someone with a large following publishes a book, they already have a marketing channel and an audience ready to buy.

3. Media Coverage and Publicity

Major media appearances (e.g., “Oprah’s Book Club,” “The Today Show,” or viral social media campaigns) can create the kind of buzz that leads to bestseller sales.

4. Timing and Trends

A book that aligns with cultural moments or emerging trends can catch fire quickly. During the COVID-19 pandemic, books about mental health, isolation, and resilience saw dramatic sales increases. Political climates, social movements, and seasonal events all influence what sells.

5. Publisher Investment

Traditional publishers often throw their weight behind a select few titles each season, offering large marketing budgets, national distribution, and coordinated campaigns designed to produce bestsellers. It’s a business decision as much as a literary one.

The Bestseller Myth: Does It Mean “Best”?

The truth is, bestseller status doesn’t always equate to literary excellence, reader satisfaction, or long-term impact. A book may top the charts for a week, only to fade quickly into obscurity. Conversely, many enduring classics—books that continue to shape culture decades after their publication—never hit the bestseller lists at all.

Consider:

  • F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby sold poorly in its initial release.

  • Moby Dick by Herman Melville was a commercial failure during the author’s lifetime.

  • To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee did eventually become a bestseller, but its long-term value far exceeds its initial commercial success.

This reveals an important truth: Longevity and influence often matter more than initial sales.

Why Chasing Bestseller Status Might Not Be the Right Goal

While bestseller status can be exhilarating and career-boosting, it’s worth asking—is that really what you want as an author?

Here are some reasons why it might not be:

1. Bestseller Lists Are Gatekept

Especially in traditional publishing, many bestseller lists are inaccessible to indie authors. Even with high sales numbers, your book might not be counted due to how and where it was sold. This makes the chase feel more like a game with hidden rules.

2. It Can Lead to Creative Compromise

When the goal becomes to sell as many books as possible, authors may feel pressured to write what’s trending rather than what’s true to their voice. This can lead to generic stories, diluted messages, and creative burnout.

3. Short-Term Thinking vs. Long-Term Impact

Bestseller lists reward spikes, not sustainability. A book that sells 50,000 copies in its first month but is forgotten six months later may have less real-world impact than a book that sells 1,000 copies a year for a decade and changes lives.

4. You Might Lose Sight of Your “Why”

Many authors start writing because they want to express something meaningful, help people, tell a story that matters, or simply enjoy the craft. Chasing bestseller status can distract from those original intentions.

A Better Question: What Do You Want Your Book to Do?

Instead of asking “How can I make my book a bestseller?”, consider asking:

  • Who is my ideal reader, and how can I reach them?

  • What transformation do I want my book to offer?

  • Will my book still matter five years from now? Ten?

  • Am I proud of what I’ve created, regardless of how it sells?

Books are powerful. They build empathy, preserve history, educate, entertain, heal, provoke, and inspire. A book that finds its right readers—even if they number in the hundreds rather than the millions—can still be profoundly successful.

Success Beyond the List

Here are some alternative definitions of success for authors:

  • A loyal reader base: A small but passionate community of readers who support your every release.

  • Speaking and consulting opportunities: Many nonfiction authors leverage their books to land high-paying speaking gigs or consulting work.

  • Critical acclaim: Awards, reviews, and academic attention can be more valuable than sales in some literary circles.

  • Impact: Hearing from readers who say your book changed their lives.

  • Creative fulfillment: The personal satisfaction of completing something deeply meaningful.

Final Thoughts: Bestseller or Not, Write the Book That Matters

There’s nothing wrong with aiming for bestseller status—especially if it aligns with your goals and values. But it shouldn’t be the only yardstick you use to measure success.

Write the book only you can write. Build connections with readers who truly resonate with your message. Focus on craft, authenticity, and impact. If your book becomes a bestseller along the way, that’s wonderful—but if it doesn’t, it can still be a legacy, a tool, a gift, and a triumph.

Because in the end, the best books aren’t always the bestsellers—and the books that matter most don’t need to top a chart to leave a mark.

Ask ChatGPT